Studies Done By Harry And Margaret Harlow Found That

The Enduring Legacy of Harlow's Monkeys: Attachment, Deprivation, and the Nature of Love

The groundbreaking research conducted by Harry and Margaret Harlow in the mid-20th century revolutionized our understanding of social and emotional development, particularly regarding the crucial role of attachment in infancy. Their experiments, though ethically controversial by today's standards, provided irrefutable evidence challenging prevailing behavioral theories and revealed the profound impact of early maternal deprivation on primate, and by implication, human development. This article delves into the key findings of the Harlow's studies, exploring their methodology, impact, and continuing relevance in contemporary developmental psychology.

Challenging the Behaviorist Paradigm: The Origins of Harlow's Research

Before the Harlows, the dominant theory in developmental psychology was behaviorism. This perspective, championed by figures like B.F. Skinner, emphasized the role of learning through reinforcement and punishment in shaping behavior. In the context of attachment, behaviorists argued that infants become attached to their caregivers primarily because they associate them with the provision of food. This "cupboard love" theory posited that the bond was purely transactional, based on the satisfaction of biological needs.

Harry Harlow, however, was deeply skeptical of this simplistic explanation. He observed that infant rhesus monkeys displayed a clear preference for physical comfort and closeness, even when food was not involved. This observation fueled his and Margaret's groundbreaking research, which sought to empirically test the behaviorist hypothesis and investigate the nature of infant attachment beyond mere biological needs.

The Wire Mother Experiments: Separating Nourishment from Comfort

The Harlows' most famous experiments involved separating infant rhesus monkeys from their mothers and providing them with two surrogate "mothers": a wire mother and a cloth mother. The wire mother was a simple construction of wire and wood, offering only food through a bottle attached to its body. The cloth mother, on the other hand, was covered in soft terrycloth, offering no nourishment but providing comfort and tactile stimulation.

The results were astonishing and directly contradicted the behaviorist predictions. Despite the wire mother providing nourishment, the infant monkeys overwhelmingly preferred the cloth mother, spending significantly more time clinging to it and seeking comfort from it. This preference was especially evident during periods of stress or fear. The infants would quickly run to the cloth mother for security and reassurance, even when the wire mother was the source of food.

These findings powerfully demonstrated that the infant's attachment to the caregiver is not solely based on the provision of food. Instead, contact comfort, the pleasurable tactile experience of soft touch and warmth, plays a crucial role in shaping the infant's emotional bond with its caregiver. This discovery was revolutionary, providing compelling evidence for the importance of emotional security and nurturing in early development.

The Long-Term Effects of Maternal Deprivation: Beyond Infancy

The Harlows' research extended beyond the immediate preference for the cloth mother. They explored the long-term consequences of maternal deprivation, raising infant monkeys with either no mother, a wire mother, or a cloth mother. The results revealed a range of profound and lasting effects on the deprived monkeys.

Monkeys raised without a mother, or with only the wire mother, displayed severe social and emotional deficits. They exhibited:

• Emotional Disturbances: Increased anxiety, fearfulness, and self-harming behaviors were common. These monkeys were often withdrawn, exhibiting signs of profound distress.

• Social Deficits: They struggled to interact appropriately with their peers, displaying abnormal social behaviors like aggression, avoidance, or excessive clinging. They were unable to form normal social relationships.

• Reproductive Problems: Many of the deprived females were inadequate mothers themselves, neglecting or even abusing their offspring, demonstrating the intergenerational transmission of trauma. Males demonstrated impaired sexual behaviors.

• Cognitive Impairments: Some studies indicated that maternal deprivation may have led to cognitive deficits, affecting learning and problem-solving abilities.

In contrast, monkeys raised with the cloth mother, while still showing some minor social and emotional difficulties, displayed significantly better outcomes. This highlighted the protective effect of even partial contact comfort in mitigating the negative consequences of early separation.

Ethical Considerations and Modern Perspectives

The Harlows' experiments, while scientifically groundbreaking, have been subjected to considerable ethical scrutiny. The prolonged isolation and distress experienced by the infant monkeys raise serious questions about the ethical permissibility of such research, particularly given the advances in our understanding of animal welfare and sentience.

Modern ethical guidelines would likely prohibit the replication of these experiments in their original form. However, the fundamental insights gained from the Harlow studies continue to inform our understanding of early childhood development, informing research conducted with far more ethical approaches, such as observational studies of primate social behaviors in natural or seminatural settings.

The Relevance of Harlow's Work to Human Development

While the Harlow studies were conducted on rhesus monkeys, their findings have profound implications for understanding human development. The emphasis on the importance of early attachment, the role of contact comfort, and the devastating effects of maternal deprivation have shaped our understanding of child psychology and influenced practices in childcare and parenting.

The Harlow studies have contributed significantly to:

• Attachment Theory: John Bowlby's attachment theory, which emphasizes the importance of the parent-child bond in shaping the child's emotional development and social relationships, draws heavily upon the Harlow's findings. The concept of secure and insecure attachment styles, a cornerstone of contemporary attachment theory, is directly related to the Harlows' observations about the impact of early experiences.

• Intervention Strategies for Children in Institutional Care: Understanding the negative consequences of maternal deprivation has led to significant improvements in the care provided to children in orphanages and institutions. Emphasis is now placed on providing nurturing and responsive care, emphasizing the importance of human contact and individual attention.

• Parenting Practices: The Harlow's work highlights the crucial role of parental sensitivity and responsiveness in fostering secure attachment. Parenting advice often emphasizes the importance of physical affection, comforting responses to the child's distress, and providing a safe and secure environment.

• Treatment of Trauma: The long-term effects of maternal deprivation observed in Harlow's monkeys inform our understanding of the effects of childhood trauma on later emotional and psychological well-being. This understanding is critical in the development of therapeutic interventions for individuals who have experienced early adversity.

Beyond Contact Comfort: The Complexity of Attachment

While contact comfort is undoubtedly a crucial factor in attachment, it's important to acknowledge the complexity of the parent-child bond. Contemporary research acknowledges that attachment is not simply a matter of physical comfort but involves a multifaceted interaction between the infant, the caregiver, and the environment. Factors such as responsiveness, sensitivity, consistency of care, and the quality of the parent-child relationship all play important roles in shaping the nature of the attachment bond.

The Continuing Legacy of Harlow's Monkeys

Despite the ethical concerns surrounding their methodology, the Harlow's experiments remain a landmark achievement in developmental psychology. Their findings have revolutionized our understanding of attachment, maternal deprivation, and the importance of early experiences in shaping social and emotional development. While contemporary research has refined and expanded upon their work, the core insights gained from Harlow's monkeys continue to influence our understanding of the human condition and inform practices aimed at promoting healthy development and well-being throughout the lifespan. The legacy of their research serves as a powerful reminder of the profound and lasting impact of early relationships on individuals and society as a whole. It's a testament to the power of scientific inquiry, even when grappling with complex and ethically challenging questions. The careful consideration of both the strengths and limitations of their work remains essential for advancing our knowledge and shaping ethical practices in the field of developmental psychology.